Please Don’t Use Social Media

by Bill Seaver on November 20, 2008

I’d like to make a request: please be quiet. Don’t say anything. Please don’t say anything at all to young adults, and especially don’t try to do it with social media tools. Don’t even think about starting a blog or creating a YouTube channel or signing up for Twitter. Please don’t begin a Facebook group, Flickr page, or launch a podcast. Don’t do any of these. Just be quiet, unless of course, you really have something to say.

Sure, young adults are using social media. According to Forrester Research’s early 2008 data, 90 percent of Americans between 18-24 years old, and 84 percent between 25-34 year olds use social media. Clearly, most young adults are online and using social media technology, but please don’t let these numbers encourage you to begin engaging them in social media unless you actually have something to say.

So how do you know if you have something to say? Start with these:

  • If you have truth to share, you have something to say.
  • If you have an experience to draw from, you have something to say.
  • If you know something I should know, you have something to say.
  • If you can tell me about someone I should meet, you have something to say.
  • If you have perspective where I am lacking, you have something to say.

The biggest misconception about social media tools is that they fix communication issues. They don’t. They merely extend the reach of what you already have to say. Therefore, if you don’t have anything to say already, you now have the opportunity to be equally ineffective to a larger number of people with the help of social media.

Social media doesn’t consist of magic beans and pixie dust. It doesn’t create something for you that wasn’t there to begin with. If you’re saying nothing today, you will say nothing in even more places with social media. Your silence will be amplified and resound with a great hollowness that would echo for eternity if not for the absence of anything there in the first place.

My advice to anyone interested in reaching young adults with social media is that they immediately forget about social media. First, figure out what you actually have to say. What is the message? What is the content you have to offer that is compelling? To what degree are you willing to engage in conversation openly and candidly with people who may want to talk to you? These are the types of questions that are appropriate to begin with. The wrong questions start with choosing technology. The technology should fit the content, not the other way around.

Content, then, becomes your focus rather than the technology. Content is the basis on which young adults will measure you in social media. Good blogs have good content. Bad blogs have bad content. The content is not good because the blog is good. The blog is good because the content made it so.

With content as the focus, and our collective desire as Christians to reach young adults, we should be reminded that there is always one well to draw from that is always rich in content: the gospel. The funny thing about the gospel is that it fits every young adult. Whether he was saved in middle school and is still learning about God’s love and grace, or she’s an atheist and shows no signs of changing her mind. The gospel says it all. The gospel is the most compelling content ever created. The gospel fuels the best conversations you can ever have.

As you consider social media as a means of reaching young adults, don’t neglect the more important task of focusing young adults on the greatest content ever told. Yes, you can reach far and wide with social media tools. Social media has become a useful and persuasive force. Its wide access and ease of use have created more opportunities for more people than media has ever provided in history. The case is compelling and seemingly irresistible, but if we want to reach young adults with these great tools and we don’t do it with content that has power, then what are we really doing? We might as well just be quiet.

About the Author

Bill Seaver is the founder of MicroExplosion Media, a social media marketing consulting firm based in Nashville. Bill helps organizations understand how to use social media through consulting services and seminars. Visit the MicroExplosion Media blog to read more from Bill or learn about specific services and seminars available to you. You can also find Bill on Twitter.

There have been 3 replies so far

Well Said. Too often people, especially those in ministry. Pastors and leaders start using these tools and then forget about them because they really don’t have a lot to say.

1 | Ben Davis

Sunday, December 7, 2008, at 8:34pm

Thanks for the comment Ben. It’s not just about having something to say. It’s about having something to say that the people you’re trying to reach will find valuable. That’s when it connects.

2 | Bill Seaver

Friday, December 12, 2008, at 12:36am

Although I totally understand your point, I have found our college Sunday School class Facebook group to be very helpful in communicating with our students. I update it weekly with information such as: announcements, birthdays, photos, prayer requests, links to helpful sites, etc. I also use it to send out invitations to events and activities. Because we have so many students who are away at college, we have found that the group site is a way to keep them connected to our class and to our church. They may be out-of-sight for much of the school year, but we want them to know that they are not out-of-mind! They are an important part of our class whether they are with us each Sunday or not. There are many times that, after sending out a group message, I have received replies from students that we haven’t seen in a very long time — asking for prayer. They know that we are there for them.

Also, when visitors come to our class I am able to send them a Facebook message or email inviting them to browse or join the group — hopefully giving them a quick way to connect with us.

We have also found that many of our Facebook group members go on to “friend” us on our personal accounts as well. This connection further opens doors to communication and relationship development. The unfortunate effect is that we sometimes are put in the position of having to decide whether or not to be what I call “The Facebook Police” when we view content on their pages that is unwise. I’d love to hear your thoughts on that issue.

Our group has been in existance for almost a year now, and we are pleased with how it has helped our ministry to our class. Student response has been positive, hopefully because (as you said) the people that we are reaching have found it to be valuable.

3 | Pam Dunnevant

Saturday, December 13, 2008, at 9:58am

Comments are closed. Please use our contact form if you have any thoughts or questions.

RSS

Articles