What Do I Really Want?

by Aaron Linne on August 23, 2007

I’m stuck with a “hard” decision. If there is something you know you want (but don’t “need”) and know you have the money for it (but there are “better” things to do with your money), and then find it at a price that’s acceptable to you (let’s hypothetically say… 40% off)… is it okay to buy it?

Let’s just be honest for a bit here and expose my struggle: the thing that I’ve been wrestling with the past few nights out to the ether of the internet: should I, or shouldn’t I, buy a PlayStation 3?

There are a few major facts that I need to disclose first, however:

  1. My wife and I are about to move into a new house. With that comes all the expenses you would expect like a refrigerator, window treatments, and a couch so that we can watch TV in our nifty new bonus room. So while we have money available… it maybe shouldn’t go to a video game.
  2. I’m a gamer by birth. I’ve been playing games all of my life, because my dad was a gamer before there was the term “gamer.” This means that I already own a Wii and an Xbox 360 (my GamerTag is “Top Rope Suplex”). So it’s not like I “need” another gaming system, I know.
  3. My wife is a big movie watcher. I’m a big comic bookay reader. The only place I can get Spider-Man, Fantastic Four and Ghost Rider in high-def is on Blu-Ray. The PS3 is the cheapest Blu-Ray player. Thus, we “need” the PS3 to watch the comic bookay movies in HD. (Ok, ok… for full disclosure… I have the HD-DVD Drive for the Xbox 360 already, too.)
I would think this would be a simple matter of finances, but instead it’s become a spiritual battle that’s kept my mind racing the past few nights.

You see, I feel like I’ve already been blessed with so much. I have a beautiful wife, wonderful friends, and now a home that Ashley and I have been dreaming of where we can entertain, feed people, and have a small group meet in our home (which we’re starting in September - much excitement). I already have two game systems… do I “need” a third?

Ultimately, my thoughts are turning to the struggle of is it okay for me to keep so much for myself? Do I even want to keep so much for myself? I feel guilty because I know we have friends who are not “struggling,” lifestyle-wise, but have chosen to live on less. We’re friends with a married couple who have two children and they’re trying to get to a point where they both only work part-time jobs so they can be home with each other more often. One of our friends chose to, just for the experience, learn how to live off of spending only one dollar a day for food. I have friends who would literally give you the shirt off their back - or the bicycle off their front porch. And here, I fret about buying another game system so that I can play a few more games.

I know I “want” it. How do I discern what wants are okay to fulfill and what wants are okay to keep on wanting? How cheap does the PS3 have to get before it is “good stewardship” to spend money on it? How much of our abundance do we give away before I stop feeling bad about keeping some for us?

I don’t imagine I’ll actually buy the PS3 anytime soon. Even though I know there’s a good deal going on for me right now that probably won’t be as cheap for another year or so… since my mind has been struggling so much about this I don’t know that I feel comfortable paying out that money just yet.

I don’t want to be overwhelmed with abundance. I want to give away what we can, but I also want to keep the appropriate amount of “stuff” for me. I don’t know that we’re supposed to give everything away, but I don’t know how much we’re supposed to hold on to, either.

I’m a gamer, and I’ll keep playing the Wii and the Xbox 360 and - more than likely - some day I’ll buy a PS3, too. I just wish it was easier to know when to do things for yourself - when it’s okay and not being selfish.

Sigh. This shouldn’t be such a spiritual struggle, should it? I mean… it’s just stuff, right?

There have been 6 replies so far

I think there is a large part of this, as guys, that makes it really difficult. In my experience guys typically gravitate toward bigger ‘things’ in their lives. For some it is a PS3. For others it might be an iPhone (guilty as charged), a bass boat, a motorcycle, etc. These are things that cost us a chunk of change and make the decision of what to do/not to do that much more difficult.

I think we probably need to strive for some balance. How much are we giving to help others vs keeping for ourselves? Is this a one-time purchase of something that will cost a little bit more than usual, or is it a habit of overspending on things that we really don’t “need?” When the opportunity comes by to spend a large amount of money on something to benefit someone else, how do we feel?

This is the kind of balance I’m striving for - and, unfortunately, only hitting a portion of the time… but I continue to try. I do think you’re right in holding off if you don’t feel comfortable with the purchase. I think God will give you peace when/if that day comes.

1 | Chris Ediger

Thursday, August 23, 2007, at 7:26am

Geezsh - I think I’ve got more to say about this than anyone will care to read. So let me just push all that aside ask you this, Aaron:

              What are <b>you</b> doing on Sept 25th?  

(I’ll be at work btw)

I will say this though: guys may think they’ve cornered the market on buying bigger “things” but the girls with the shoes and the purses and the ipods and with the kitchen appliances and the jewelry…

I’m just saying.

2 | benny

Friday, August 24, 2007, at 12:04am

Sept 25th?

I’m going to finish the fight. After work, of course.

(oi, i’m such a geek.)

3 | Aaron Linne

Friday, August 24, 2007, at 10:39am

Aaron:

Its just stuff man. I can relate as a guy, that you always want the new shinny thing. After the PS3 it will be something else, that just how we are wired.

My advice, get your wife in on the conversation. To me window treatments are a waste of cash, and that new couch is a waste as well seeing the one we’ve had for 10 years (given to us by neighbors) works just fine.

One way to do this start doing a monthly budget and include your short term and long term wants (not needs) and their accociated costs. Dave Ramsey has an excellent book on the subject, and it has stopped many a fight in my home, especially when I had the great idea of buying a boat this spring. My wifey gently shot me down because it wasn’t in the budget.

Good Luck

4 | Tofu

Friday, August 24, 2007, at 11:04am

I dont know where your monies are in your life but the first thing I would ask is do you Tithe? and not just money.

God also wants 10% of time and talent.

Will this consume too much of the other (time and talent)

I am a computer nerd so I can relate to the other stuff

Just a little food for the the husband and wife meeting on daily and long term goals

5 | chilller

Tuesday, September 4, 2007, at 8:21am

This is a great article. The fact that your struggling with the decisions is far far more then most people ever care to even do. It is quite obvious when you look at scripture and the way that Christ choose to live his life, that our following his example will result in these struggles, and sometimes decisions that don’t look quite like our consumer culture.

6 | ariahfine

Tuesday, September 4, 2007, at 10:20pm

Comments are closed. Please use our contact form if you have any thoughts or questions.

Articles