How Do We Treat Lost Sheep?

by Jim Johnston on November 14, 2007

Not long ago, I met an engaging young lady at a conference I was attending. In the course of our conversation, she told me she was the mother of a new baby, which prompted me to ask about her family and then about her husband’s career. She politely corrected me and told me where her partner worked.

This immediately got me to thinking and praying about how a Christ-follower and churches should engage people who embrace a homosexual lifestyle.

Should I treat her any differently than any other person who needs to know the love of Christ and the freedom His sacrifice for us brings? If this couple came to my church hand-in-hand and wanted to check their baby into the preschool, how would they be treated? If they walked into our worship service, would they be welcomed?

Would they belong?

Check out Luke 15, where the religious establishment was complaining about Jesus’ association with sinners. Jesus’ response was to tell four straight parables - The Lost Sheep, The Lost Coin, The Lost Son, and The Dishonest Manager - that reveal His GREAT love for everyone who has fallen short of the glory of God, and our responsibility as believers to love them and help them find their way to Him.

We don’t stop people who are obese at the front door of the church and tell them they need to lose weight and control their eating before they are welcome - even though the Bible says gluttony is a sin. If we did, I would be camped in the parking lot every Sunday.

We don’t forbid known liars to enter a worship service, even though Commandment No. 9 clearly teaches bearing false witness is a sin. Again, I would never be welcome inside.

Basically, here is my take on a person who practices homosexuality…

The Bible clearly teaches homosexuality is a sin, just like it teaches that lying, gluttony, having sex outside of marriage, worshipping money and all that it buys are sins. There are plenty of directives in the Bible that make me uncomfortable because it shines a light on behaviors of mine and thoughts that are clearly not holy and godly. So, I am in the same boat with anyone who chooses homosexuality, who doesn’t enjoy reading the Bible passages who define homosexuality as sin.

I am not advocating allowing homosexuals to lead or serve in a church, any more that I would advocate allowing any person to serve as a church leader whose lifestyle did not match a Biblical blueprint for enjoying this privilege.

Here is my point: The homosexual community is a growing group of people in our society. We cannot ignore them or treat them like modern-day lepers.

We need to treat them as lost sheep - just like Jesus treats us.

About the Author

Jim Johnston has worked in a variety of roles, ranging from marketing to publishing to Internet development. Prior to coming to LifeWay, he worked as a reporter and editor for the Montgomery Advertiser and also as an adult-in-missions editor at the Brotherhood Commission in Memphis. Jim and his wife Tammy have been married for 23 years and have two sons, Spenser, 17, and Ethan, 10.

There have been 10 replies so far

I saw a great movie this weekend that really demonstrates the idea you hit on in your blog, choosing love over judgment. The situation was different but the basic idea was the same. People are valuable and we are all crazy in our own way- so why not choose to love. The movie was Lars and the Real Girl. You should go see it and let me know what you think!

1 | Heather Manning

Thursday, November 15, 2007, at 2:31pm

This movie you are talking about is on my must see list along with Bella and Into the Wild. I will check it out. jj

2 | Jim Johnston

Thursday, November 15, 2007, at 2:42pm

However…….Do you think Jesus let them know up front that he detest their sinful behavior? What I’m getting at is that when we accept the person, we often accept the sin, also. I am presently struggling with this very situation. My sister-in-law is homosexual and after many years of “hiding” it, she revealed her lifestyle to my wife and I, even though I was 99.9% sure she was before the reveal. She knows that we don’t approve of this lifestyle and why. But now I feel like if I don’t speak to her about her lifestyle, she will assume that I’ve accepted it, simply because I accept her. I don’t know if any of this makes sense, but I’m just not sure if I should ignore the way she lives and just love her or bring it up every chance I get. And to top it all off, she professes to be a born-again believer.

3 | Deacon

Thursday, November 15, 2007, at 4:04pm

Deacon, I am living in your world. I can relate. The only way we know how Jesus would respond is from the Bible. His encounter with the Samaritan women at the well, recorded in John 4:9 has been my guide. First, Jesus broke tradition and political practice by talking to her and treating her like a human being, even though talking to a woman and Samaritan was strictly out of bounds. So he showed CLEARLY that she mattered and he cared for her. Second, he told her about salvation, that there was better life for people willing to drink “living water” and follow after Him. Third, he confronted her sin by revealing to her that He knew about her past (even before they met in person) and yet was still willing to embrace her — while still calling her to a better life and a different life without sexual sin. Same issue with the women caught in adultery, in John 8:4. Jesus stepped in and saved the women caught in adultery from the scribes and the Pharisees. He let her know He cared about her and valued her life. He stepped in front of the mob and saved her from a horrible death from stoning. Then He told her, “Go and sin no more.” I think she heard him clearly because she knew He loved her. Enough to defend her. My advice is, follow His lead in the situation you are in.

4 | Jim Johnston

Thursday, November 15, 2007, at 5:45pm

One other important point from John 8:4. Jesus didn’t condemn the woman caught in adultery. He didn’t really dwell on the past. He went right to a better future for this woman. That is unbelievably important for any sinner —- like me or your sister in law. You have to be able to clearly see a better future ahead. You have to see hope. Jesus is all about giving hope to a hopeless world. That’s why I am all about giving hope to anyone caught in sexual sin of any kind.

5 | Jim Johnston

Thursday, November 15, 2007, at 5:52pm

Jiim I really appreciate your taking this issue to scriptures and pulling away from the issue of homesexuality to the bigger subject of sexual sin. It seems so simple- even trite sometimes to think about what Jesus did but it also seems freeing to me. I have several friends who struggle with issues likes these, as do I, and I personal probably fall to far to the acceptance side rather than the speaking side of the issue but it is really refreshing to have you point back to Jesus words and his actions. And I can’t help but feel like life has shown me that the greater call is to love. At times that has clearly meant speaking but more often it has meant trusting that the Holy Spirit that is living within me is capable of leading me and my friends with out my having to be their Holy Spirit.

PS- I have seen Bella and Into the Wild, as has Valerie, so I think we are due a good roundtable about all three of these movies!

6 | Heather Manning

Thursday, November 15, 2007, at 7:48pm

Jim, I appreciate and agree with your perspective. Here is a fine point that we are dealing with in regard to this topic. Our church is in an area with a large homosexual population and we have loving, caring relationships with many of this community. Recently a lesbian couple has been attending our church, which is great, but some parents in the congregation have been uncomfortable with the couple’s mild public displays of affection in front of children in the church. This display may lead to questions and require a premature explanation of homosexuality to the children. While the couple is very welcome as are all of us who sin, their actions are probably not something that parents can accomodate before their young children. What is your take on this and how would you respond?

7 | Cynthia Thompson

Friday, November 16, 2007, at 8:29am

Jim, thank you for the biblical insight, however she believes her present “partner” is hope sent by God because of past relationships that have gone badly. I believe that she doesn’t see her relationship as sin. She is attending a church where she is embraced (no problem with that) and her lifestyle is accepted (big problem witht that). So, she is being confirmed every week. Anyway, Thanksgiving is next week and I’m debating on whether or not to bring it up, seeing how it hasn’t been brought up since the reveal. I will try and meditate on John 4 & 8 until then.

8 | Deacon

Friday, November 16, 2007, at 9:22am

Cynthia, I think the best way to deal with the situation you describe is to deal with it head on. Someone with the best relationship with the couple needs to sit down with them and lovingly tell them how this is being received. Let them know they are accepted by the church, but ask them if they would refrain from this kind of behavior for the same reason we would ask teenagers who engage in undue public displays of affection to refrain. I think this situation is a great way to begin the conversation about how the Bible views a homosexual relatiionship, provided it is handled with love and care. If the couple responds with hostility, it is probably a sign that they are being convicted, but not ready to start thinking about giving up this stronghold in their lives. Tough situation. Any other takes on this situation? jj

9 | Jim Johnston

Friday, November 16, 2007, at 10:50am

Deacon, Prayer is the best way to approach what you should do in this situation. I am going to pray that God grants you His perfect wisdom about how best to approach your sister in law. Your posts here tell me that you are going to handle this in a godly and wonderful way. Good things are going to happen in this situation. jj

10 | Jim Johnston

Friday, November 16, 2007, at 10:52am

Comments are closed. Please use our contact form if you have any thoughts or questions.

Articles